Ex parte PAYNE et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1999-2235                                                        
          Application No. 08/577,493                                                  


          any disclosure for the perpendicular component of the magnetic              
          signal being the maximum component.                                         
               Appellants (Brief, page 12) refer to Figure 3 and the                  
          associated text in the specification.  According to                         
          appellants, as shown by the graph of Figure 3, the maximum                  
          perpendicularly oriented field component of the magnetic                    
          signal is greater than the maximum longitudinal field                       
          component only when the perpendicular distance D from the head              
          is a fraction of the amagnetic gap G.  Distance D includes any              
          airgap and the combined thicknesses of any overcoats and                    
          lubricant on the media layer.                                               
               Chapman has a proposed gap dimension of 0.25 micron.                   
          Chapman does not disclose the specifics of the media layer.                 
          Although Hamilton may suggest contact between the head and the              
          media layer, thereby eliminating an airgap from the distance                
          D, Hamilton does not disclose whether the media layer includes              
          an overcoat layer and/or lubricant, and, if so, what the                    
          thickness thereof would be.  Therefore, it is unclear from the              
          evidence provided by the examiner whether the value of D would              
          be a fraction of the gap G, such that the perpendicular                     
          magnetic field component would be maximum.  Further the                     
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007