Ex Parte HAYHURST - Page 5





            Appeal No. 1999-2728                                                   Page 5              
            Application No. 08/423,963                                                                 


            (Richards).3  With regard to Ogiu, we direct the examiner’s                                
            attention to the suturing thread 9 and cylindrical stop 7, for                             
            example.  The surgical fastener of Richards, comprising filament                           
            10 and head 15, discussed on pages 5-11 and illustrated in                                 
            Figures 1-6, appears pertinent to appellant’s claimed invention.                           






























                  3 These references were cited by appellant in Paper No. 9 and copies are             
            of record in the application file.  The publication date of Richards is March              
            12, 1987, subsequent to the filing dates of the earliest three applications in             
            the continuity chain of the instant application.  It thus follows that any                 
            determination as to the patentability of the claims over Richards involves a               
            determination as to the effective filing date to which any such claim is                   
            entitled under 35 U.S.C. § 120.                                                            






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007