FLANDERS et al v. MOORMAN et al - Page 9




          Interference No. 103,891                                                    



          inasmuch as Moorman must argue his priority case in his main                
          brief.  In the second part, Moorman responds specifically to the            
          argument of Flanders respecting whether Moorman has shown a                 
          reduction to practice of that portion of the count that requires            
          the analyte of interest in solulizible form to be part of the               
          positive control.  As to the first part, it is entitled to no               
          consideration, whatsoever.  For example, we will not consider the           
          work done in November argued at pages 4-7 of the surreply and               
          thereafter.  This material is part of Moorman’s case-in-chief               
          and must be in the main brief to be entitled to consideration.              
          Additionally, any argument directed to the equivalence of                   
          Moorman’s case-in-chief and Flanders’ case-in-chief was ripe for            
          argument in Moorman’s main brief and is not entitled to consider-           
          ation when presented in a surreply.  This applies to section C.             
          of the surreply found on pages 7-10.  Furthermore, on page 13,              
          Moorman offers a count construction.  Moorman did not construe              
          the count in his main brief.  This material will not be consid-             
          ered.  As to the other part of the surreply, we will review these           
          specific arguments of Moorman when we consider Moorman’s priority           
          case.                                                                       






                                          9                                           





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007