Appeal No. 2000-0073 Application No. 08/883,716 wherein M equals Sn, Ti, Fe, Cu, Nb, Ta, Co, Ni, Mg, Li, Na, Ga and mixtures thereof, a is from about 0.5 to about 5.0, b is from about 0.1 to 5.0, and x is the number of oxygen atoms required to satisfy the valency requirement of the other elements. comprising (1) mixing the vanadium compound, at least a portion of the antimony compound, and at least a portion of the M compound and an aqueous sol containing a portion of the support material to form an aqueous slurry, heating the slurry to remove the water, and calcining at a temperature of at least about 150°C to form a catalyst precursor; (2) mixing the catalyst precursor with an aqueous sol containing the remaining portion of the support for the catalyst and any remaining portion of the Sb compound and M compound to form a second slurry; (3) drying the second slurry to remove the water to form a dry mixture; and (4) calcining the dried mixture at a temperature of at least 150°C to form the finished catalyst. As evidence of unpatentability of the claimed subject matter, the Examiner relies on the following references: Brazdil et al. (Brazdil ‘016) 5,214,016 May 25, 1993 Brazdil et al. (Brazdil ‘588) 5,498,588 Mar. 12, 1996 -3-Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007