Ex parte SHAIKH et al. - Page 7




              Appeal No. 2000-0093                                                                                       
              Application No. 08/874,812                                                                                 

                     upon this 3-D data, cross-sectional-shape data is obtained for each shape                           
                     of a plurality of parallel cross-sections obtained in the whole image of the                        
                     mold at every given interval.  Subsequently, based upon the cross-                                  
                     sectional-shape data obtained in this manner, from a material for                                   
                     full-mold-casting models, such as styrofoam board, etc., multiple board                             
                     pieces are prepared which have the external shapes corresponding to the                             
                     shapes of the parallel cross-sections that are described by the                                     
                     cross-sectional-shape data [translation, page 6].                                                   
                     Tamura '541 also discloses that the multiple board pieces are shaped by an                          
              automatic cutting device under control of the processor (see, for example, page 17 in                      
              the translation).                                                                                          
                     The preambles of claims 1, 8, 13 and 26, the four independent claims on appeal,                     
              define the methods respectively recited therein as being for “making a casting having                      
              free-form, undercut or hidden interior surfaces” (claim 1), “making a casting having                       
              complex free-form, undercut or substantially hidden interior surfaces” (claim 8), “making                  
              a functional casting from molten castable material, said casting having interior surfaces                  
              which are shaped with two or more characteristic[s] of free-form, undercut or hidden”                      
              (claim 13) and “making a fugitive investment pattern having free-form, undercut or                         


              hidden interior surfaces” (claim 26).  Each of these claims also sets forth a “carving”                    
              step relating to the formation of such interior surfaces.  In applying the Tamura                          
              references against the appealed claims, the examiner takes the position that                               
                     each of prior art references substantially shows the invention as claimed                           
                     except that they do not disclose [how] to make a casting having free-from                           


                                                           7                                                             





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007