Ex Parte SMITH - Page 6



          Appeal No. 2000-0358                                                        
          Application No. 08/678,409                                                  

          and claim 15 includes the limitation, "said computer system                 
          comprising . . . a mechanism configured to cause a new access               
          right to be acquired by said virtual input device by causing the            
          first object to interact with a second object representing access           
          rights of said virtual input devices."  Reading these claims as             
          broadly as reasonably allowed, claim 8 requires the data                    
          representing sequences of instructions of a machine readable                
          medium executed on a computer system to cause the system to                 
          perform the step of acquiring said new access right by said                 
          virtual input device by causing the first object to interact with           
          a second object representing access rights of said virtual input            
          device, and claim 15 requires a mechanism of a computer system to           
          be capable of or configured to cause a new access right to be               
          acquired by said virtual input device by causing the first object           
          to interact with a second object representing access rights of              
          said virtual input device.                                                  
               Appellant argues that Bly et al. (Bly) does not disclose the           
          step of the virtual input device acquiring a new access right by            
          causing a first object to interact with a second object                     
          representing access rights of the virtual input device.  Appeal             
          Brief, page 5, lines 23-25.  More specifically, Appellant states            
          that if the record is the recited second object, the record does            
                                          6                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007