Ex Parte BERSON et al - Page 9



          Appeal No. 2000-1185                                       Page 9           
          Application No. 08/886,516                                                  

          light, the otherwise unobservable mark becomes detectable and               
          provides encoded data related to the identity and source of the             
          articles.  In particular, using an invisible ink or dye, a unique           
          pattern is applied to the articles which incorporates an encoded            
          input data entry comprising unique product identifiers.  The                
          pattern become detectable upon exposure to light with a specific            
          wavelength and may be scanned and decoded in order to retrieve              
          the input data and to determine authenticity of the article (col.           
          5, lines 41-59 and col. 15, lines 55-64).  Therefore, Moore’s               
          unique pattern is not separate from the article information and             
          itself includes encoded data corresponding to specific product              
          information for identifying the article and its source.                     
               Turning to Salive, we find that the disclosed machine-                 
          readable characters and/or coded indicia printed onto labels and            
          affixed to articles are detected and recorded for identification            
          and tracking (col. 1, lines 7-10 and 31-34).  The captured image            
          is stored in a computer for subsequent analysis and inventory               
          tracking during and after handling.  Therefore, Salive merely               
          captures the encoded image of product data available on a label             
          for tracking goods in a warehouse or during distribution.  We               
          find that Salive is not concerned with verifying the authenticity           
          of the goods and does not teach a label having an unreproduceable           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007