Ex parte BURCH - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2000-1302                                       Page 6           
          Application No. 08/766,057                                                  

               Ericson teaches that, in making a composite article                    
          having a resilient core, such as polyurethane foam, for                     
          example, united with an overlying vinyl cover skin, airless                 
          spraying of the vinyl polymer skin material onto the mold                   
          presents advantages over forming the skin by rotational                     
          (rotary) casting and slush molding (column 1, line 30 et                    
          seq.).                                                                      
               In our view, one skilled in the art reading the combined               
          teachings of Hoskinson and Ericson would have been led to form              
          the integrally molded seat cushion unit comprising wood having              
          an elastomer skinned urethane foam adhered thereto for                      
          repairing damaged bus seats of the admitted prior art by                    
          spraying the vinyl                                                          
          polymer onto the mold surface, inserting a wood reinforcement               
          into the mold, filling the mold with foamable material and                  
          allowing the foamable material to foam.  We have considered                 
          appellant’s argument in the reply brief that one skilled in                 
          the art having both Hoskinson and Ericson before him/her would              
          be confused and would not look to combine their teachings, but              
          we do not agree.  From our perspective, one skilled in the art              
          having knowledge of the teachings of both Hoskinson and                     








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007