Ex parte PAYNE - Page 6




              Appeal No. 2000-1487                                                                  Page 6                
              Application No. 08/786,373                                                                                  


              an illuminated sign housing assembly particularly for a school bus; Chudzik discloses a                     
              removable auxiliary taillight assembly for use on trailers or on vehicles equipped with racks               
              or carriers for various objects, such as bicycles, skis, etc. which can obstruct the taillights             
              of the vehicle; and Rubin discloses an illuminated vehicle sign adapted for mounting on the                 
              sides of a vehicle, such as a panel truck or a truck trailer.  None of Lamparter, Chudzik and               
              Rubin provides any teaching or suggestion to provide an illuminated sign or lights on a                     
              trailer in the particular location called for in claim 1.  Accordingly, we shall not sustain the            
              examiner’s rejections of claim 3 as being unpatentable over Koch in view of Barry and                       
              Lamparter, claim 4 as being unpatentable over Koch in view of Barry and Chudzik, claim 5                    
              as being unpatentable over Koch in view of Barry and Godbersen and claim 10 as being                        
              unpatentable over Koch in view of Barry and Rubin.                                                          

























Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007