Ex parte BAKER et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2000-1524                                                        
          Application No. 08/943,711                                                  


          any Java application “operable to dynamically specify the                   
          grammar...”  Moreover, even if Sarukkai could be interpreted                
          to find an application program interface between the Java                   
          application and a speech recognition server, there is                       
          certainly no indication therein that any such interface would               
          be operable in a two-way manner, as required by the instant                 
          claims.  That is, the instant claimed subject matter provides               
          for the speech recognition server to receive a grammar and a                
          speech input and to output a speech recognition result based                
          on these inputs.  The Java application specifies the grammar                
          and also receives the result from the speech recognition                    
          server.  The Java application performs an action based on the               
          speech recognition server result.  An application program                   
          interface provides for this two-way communication between the               
          Java application specifying the grammar and the speech                      
          recognition server receiving the grammar, performing a                      
          processing operation based on the grammar and a speech input,               
          and sending a result back to the Java application.  No such                 
          two-way communication between a speech recognition server and               
          a Java application, via an application program interface, is                
          indicated in the disclosure of Sarukkai.  Thus, even if                     
                                         -6–                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007