Ex Parte SOHN et al - Page 6



          Appeal No. 2000-1765                                                        
          Application No. 08/947,895                                                  
          in a disk player due to an eccentric center of gravity of a disk,           
          which is the claimed invention of Appellants, but instead is                
          concerned with the problem of balancing an abrupt unbalance of a            
          rotational shaft during a high-speed rotation in rotary spray               
          type metal powder manufacturing apparatus.  See Araki, page 3,              
          lines 25-26, and page 4, lines 1-2.  In describing the problem              
          Araki seeks to solve, Araki discloses that in the metal powder              
          manufacturing apparatus, a part of a metallic piece cooled and              
          fixed to the upper surface of a disc installed at the upper end             
          of a perpendicular rotational shaft is dropped from the disc                
          during the manufacture of the metal powder.  The dropping of the            
          metallic piece causes abrupt unbalance in the rotational shaft              
          during a high-speed rotation, likely causing damage to the                  
          bearing supporting the rotational shaft and the rotor.  See                 
          Araki, page 2, lines 13-19 and 4-6.                                         
               Thus, Araki is not concerned with the problem of dampening             
          internal vibrations in a disc player generated by the rotation of           
          the spindle motor due to an eccentric center of gravity of the              
          disc.  Araki does not solve problems caused when a disk with an             
          eccentric center of gravity caused by a discrepancy between the             
          rotational center of the disk and the center of gravity of the              
          disk due to errors in the manufacturing process of the disk is              

                                          6                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007