Appeal No. 2000-1833 Application 09/002,650 Representative claim 1 reads as follows: 1. A portable shelf for mounting on a wall affixed towel bar of width W that is spaced a distance N from the wall, comprising: a plurality of rods each having an essentially uniform cross-section; a plurality of brackets each having a top, back, bottom and front where said top has a plurality of through-openings that are aligned horizontally and that have a cross-section that is essentially the same as said rod’s cross-section, said back has a vertical edge, said bottom has at least one through-opening that has a cross-section that is essentially the same as said rod’s cross- section, and said front extends downward from a point that is more than N distant from said back’s vertical edge to a point that is less than N distant from said back’s vertical edge; and said rods and said brackets are connected by sliding each of said rods within each similar one of said through-openings such that the outermost of said brackets are spaced less then W, whereby a shelf that can be supported by the towel bar and the wall is effected. THE PRIOR ART The references relied on by the examiner as evidence of obviousness are: Whitehead et al. (Whitehead) 5,706,737 Jan. 13, 1998 Adams 5,711,434 Jan. 27, 1998 2Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007