Ex Parte GAHANG - Page 9



          Appeal No. 2000-2057                                                        
          Application 08/838,791                                                      

          Gahang.  Finally, appellant argues that there is no teaching of             
          the claimed storing step during a first mode of operation in                
          Gahang [brief, pages 20-23].                                                
          The examiner responds that the portion of Augusti relied                    
          on in the rejection relates to shading correction and not to                
          half-tone processing [answer, pages 13-14].                                 
          We will not sustain this rejection of claims 1-10 because                   
          we agree with appellant that the values stored in advance in                
          EPROM 32 of Augusti do not constitute a preset maximum brightness           
          value as claimed.  Augusti describes these preset values as                 
          resulting from a ratio between the direct reading signal of a               
          pixel and that recorded in the RAM 31 in the preliminary reading            
          of the corresponding pixel of the sample strip 29 [page 5].  Both           
          of these values which make up the ratio are measured values and             
          not maximum values preset by the user.  Although these stored               
          values may have a theoretical maximum, the system of Augusti does           
          not preset this theoretical maximum in the memory.  As noted                
          above, one of the key features of appellant’s invention is to               
          avoid the calculation of shading factors based on measured                  
          parameters.                                                                 



                                          9                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007