Ex Parte KOHR et al - Page 7


          Appeal No. 2001-0127                                                        
          Application No. 09/121,636                                                  

               The relied upon evidence, however, lacks a comparison of               
          the claimed invention against the closest prior art, which is an            
          aqueous composition comprising an acrylic polymer having a Tg of            
          21-43°C and containing 30-60% by weight of butyl methacrylate,              
          20% by weight of acetoacetoxy ethyl methacrylate, and 10% by                
          weight of acrylic acid.  In re Baxter Travenol Labs, 952 F.2d               
          388, 392, 21 USPQ 1281, 1285 (Fed. Cir. 1991) ("[R]esults must              
          be shown to be unexpected compared with the closest prior                   
          art.").                                                                     
               Furthermore, the relied upon evidence is not commensurate              
          in scope with the claims.  In re Kulling, 897 F.2d 1147, 1149,              
          14 USPQ2d 1056, 1058 (Fed. Cir. 1990)("'[O]bjective evidence of             
          nonobviousness must be commensurate in scope with the claims.'";            
          (quoting In re Lindner, 457 F.2d 506, 508, 173 USPQ 356, 358                
          (CCPA 1972)); In re Dill, 604 F.2d 1356, 1361, 202 USPQ 805, 808            
          (CCPA 1979) ("The evidence presented to rebut a prima facie case            
          of obviousness must be commensurate in scope with the claims to             
          which it pertains.").                                                       
               In this regard, Polymers B and D are limited to those                  
          containing 10 or 20% by weight of isobutyl methacrylate, 25 or              
          35% by weight of butyl methacrylate, 45% by weight of styrene,              
          and 10% by weight of methacrylic acid.  By contrast, appealed               


                                          7                                           


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007