Ex Parte HOFFMAN et al - Page 6


         Appeal No. 2001-0131                                                       
         Application No. 08/977,110                                                 

              degradative modes is sufficient basis to utilize an                   
              alkali metal oxide, alone or with calcium stearate                    
              when one or more antioxidants comprising a phenolic                   
              antioxidant  and [sic] an organic phosphite known to                  
              be suitable as melt stabilizers are present in olefin                 
              resins containing a polyester, polystyrene and PVC.                   
              We cannot agree with the examiner’s analysis.  Burns                  
         discloses a stabilizer system for C2 to C8 olefin polymers                 
         comprising at least one pentaerythritol phosphite compound and             
         at least one alkaline earth metal oxide (e.g., CaO).  (Abstract;           
         column 1, lines 35-39; column 2, lines 8-10.)  According to                
         Burns, the pentaerythritol phosphite compounds “provide                    
         excellent color stability as well as suppress odors” but are               
         “very sensitive to moisture and consequently undergo degradation           
         at high temperatures.”  (Column 1, lines 16-26.)  Burns solves             
         the degradation problem of pentaerythritol phosphite, which is             
         said to be an otherwise excellent color stabilizer, by adding an           
         alkaline earth metal oxide.  (Column 1, lines 35-39.)  Burns               
         further teaches that a hindered phenol (e.g., octadecyl[(3-(3,5-           
         di-t-butyl-4-hydroxyphenyl)]propionate) may also be included.              
         (Column 2, lines 12-39.)                                                   
              The present specification acknowledges that the recited               
         component “b)” is known as a stabilizer for plastics.  (Page 9,            
         third and fourth paragraphs.)                                              



                                         6                                          


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007