Ex Parte GALLAGHER et al - Page 6



          Appeal No. 2001-0164                                                        
          Application No. 08/885,379                                                  
               In addition, the Examiner takes the position that the return           
          step (214) discussed in column 11, line 47 of Bealkowski is the             
          same as repeating "the aforementioned sequential search of the              
          possible operating system sources" recited in claim 1.  See                 
          Examiner's Answer on page 5, lines 6-12.  An examination of                 
          Figure 6B, column 4, lines 8-9, and in column 11, lines 38-60 of            
          Bealkowski demonstrates that the return step (214) is within a              
          single source, such as the fixed disk.  The sequence attempts               
          ninety-nine times to read a boot record from the fixed disk.                
          Each time an error occurs within an attempt the sequence returns.           
          However, once all sources are checked and none are found to be              
          both operational and have a valid boot format, the CPU does not             
          "repeat the aforementioned sequential search of the possible                
          operating system sources" as recited in claim 1.  Rather,                   
          Bealkowski discloses in column 10, lines 1 through 4 that the               
          system halts.                                                               
               Thus, we find that Bealkowski does not recite the step of              
          "if all sources are checked and none are both operational and has           
          a valid boot format, having the CPU repeat the aforementioned               
          search of the possible operating system sources" recited in claim           
          1.                                                                          


                                          6                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007