Ex Parte RUDZEWITZ et al - Page 7



         Appeal No. 2001-0350                                                       
         Application 09/243,835                                                     

         plate lockup mechanisms to affix a printing plate to a printing            
         cylinder.  As noted by the examiner, Sugiyama and Nobuta do                
         specifically indicate the importance in the art of minimizing              
         downtime of a printing press in the process of affixing a new              
         plate thereto.  The same problem to be overcome is recognized              
         according to the prior art discussion of appellants at pages 1-3           
         of the specification as filed.  Although we agree with                     
         appellants' recognition that Sugiyama does not deal with plate             
         alignment registration as set forth at the bottom of page 10 of            
         the brief, Nobuta's teachings appear to focus upon placement of a          
         printing plate in a plate feeding device for proper axial                  
         alignment to a print cylinder PC.                                          
              On the basis of the teachings and suggestions of Wieland in           
         view of Sugiyama and Nobuta alone, we find that it would have              
         been obvious for the artisan to have applied the teachings of              
         Wieland's pre-registration device to a more traditional clamped-           
         type printing press approach as noted in Sugiyama and Nobuta.              
         The same may be said of applying such teachings to Lindner, a              
         printing press of the type utilizing a traditional plate lockup            
         approach to affixing the printing plate to the print drum itself.          


                                          7                                         




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007