Ex Parte GRIMSRUD et al - Page 7




         Appeal No. 2001-0462                                                      
         Application 08/885,325                                                    


              As noted by the examiner, the block arranger in Figure 1 of          
         Akyürek essentially teaches the feature of analyzing trace data           
         and then essentially generating a new or updated set of logical           
         files having a correspondence to physical, reserved space                 
         locations in the disk of Figure 1 as set forth at the end of              
         representative claim 20 on appeal.                                        
              As a final matter, the virtual memory comments made by the           
         examiner in the Advisory Action appear to us to be subject to             
         being misconstrued.  It appears to us that the examiner is merely         
         attempting to convey to the reader that within the concept of             
         virtual addressing, there is a translation or mapping operation           
         of logical to physical addresses.  Appellants's arguments at              
         pages 8 and 9 of the brief confirm the well-known generalized             
         understanding in the art for virtual addressing techniques but            
         are not persuasive to us of patentability of the presently                
         claimed subject matter.  The environment of the claims is not             
         specific to virtual memory operations, although they appear to            
         encompass, because of their breadth, the subject matter of                
         virtual addressing.  Logical addressing techniques may occur in           






                                         7                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007