Ex Parte INAMINE - Page 4




           Appeal No. 2001-0830                                                                      
           Application No. 08/917,718                                                                


           received from the computer, relying on column 11, lines 51-60,                            
           and Figure 19 of Kashiwazaki.                                                             
                 Referring to the cited portions of Kashiwazaki, column 11,                          
           lines 50-60, does mention “head data” and column 15, lines 4-10,                          
           does mention a pair of print data and an emulation designation                            
           command.  CPU 22 does control the overall operation of                                    
           Kashiwazaki’s apparatus.  However, the examiner’s rationale is                            
           unclear as to how these various portions of Kashiwazaki are tied                          
           together.  Moreover, when we refer to the cited portions at                               
           column 7, lines 34-37, and column 9, lines 37-45, we do not find                          
           any teaching or suggestion of a determination as to whether the                           
           data input is print data or environment setting data based on a                           
           header code included in the header portion of the data received                           
           from the computer, as claimed.                                                            
                 At column 7, it is recited that the CPU 22 determines                               
           whether all the I/Fs 21a and 21b are set in an on-line state.  It                         
           is true that I/F 21a is interrupted when print data is output                             
           from an external apparatus so the cited portion of column 7 may                           
           be found to suggest that the CPU determines if the data input is                          
           print data.  At column 9, Kashiwazaki discloses that the external                         
           apparatus sends a control command for downloading font scaler                             
           data to the apparatus, “a code representing that the download                             
                                                -4–                                                  





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007