Ex Parte LEE - Page 5



          Appeal No. 2001-1571                                                        
          Application 08/958,844                                                      

          or NAP, respectively.  Further Ng discloses that an incoming DAR            
          is considered to be sequential if the requested data block medium           
          storage address is contiguous to the medium storage address of              
          the immediately previous requested data block.  We find that the            
          thrust of the invention in Ng is to detect the pattern of the               
          incoming data access requests, and depending upon the nature of             
          the request, the data is either supplied in a sequential manner             
          (BOM) or in a circular or non-sequential manner (COM).                      
               We do not find, and the Examiner has not pointed out in his            
          rejection or in his response to the arguments, where, in Ng, the            
          recited limitations of “first data corresponding in size to said            
          constant unit storage region and taken from a series of data                
          after said correspond data, and storing said first data in said             
          constant unit storage region (Claim 1, lines 7-9)” is found.  In            
          contrast, in Ng the data request is coming at a rate which is not           
          responsive to the size of the constant unit of the storage.                 
               Considering independent claim 3, after reviewing Examiner’s            
          rejection Appellant’s arguments and Examiner’s response to the              
          arguments, we again do not find, neither has the Examiner pointed           
          out, where Ng discloses the recited limitations of “temporarily             
          storing said corresponding data in a partial region of said unit            
          storage region of said data transmission storage device (Claim 3,           
                                         -5-                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007