Ex Parte DAUM - Page 2



            Appeal No. 2001-2074                                                                      
            Application 08/552,143                                                                    


            rejection.  These are the only claims remaining in the                                    
            application.                                                                              
                        The claimed invention is a deflectable needle assembly                        
            that can be inserted in an obstructed site in a body.  The needle                         
            assembly includes a straight rigid cannula, a catheter with a                             
            curved distal end, and a stylet inserted in the catheter.  When                           
            the catheter with the curved distal end is withdrawn into the                             
            straight cannula, since the catheter is made of superelastic                              
            material, the curved catheter assumes the shape of the straight                           
            cannula.                                                                                  
                        The claimed subject matter may be further understood                          
            with reference to the appealed claims appended to appellant’s                             
            Brief.                                                                                    
                        The references of record relied upon by the examiner as                       
            evidence of obviousness are:                                                              
            Hillstead                5,066,285                Nov. 19, 1991                           
            Daum                     DE 4223897 A1            Jan. 27, 19941                          
            (German Offenlegungsschrift)                                                              



            1 Our understanding of the German reference is via a translation                          
            into English prepared by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.                            
                                                  2                                                   




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007