Appeal No. 2001-2278 Application No. 09/304,267 from “0” to “1.” If the flag is found to have changed from “0” to “1,” step 502 is reached. In step 502, the CPU 32 sets the accumulated intake air quantity QASUM to “QACLO” and stores it. The accumulated intake air quantity QASUM is an accumulation of the intake air quantity QA calculated since the start-up of the engine. The calculation is performed by an accumulated intake air quantity calculating routine shown in FIG. 7. In carrying out the routine of FIG. 7, the CPU 32 checks in step 601 to see if the engine is started illustratively by turning on the ignition key. If the engine is found to be started (ignition key=ON), step 602 is reached. In step 602, the CPU 32 updates the accumulated intake air quantity QASUM by adding to the current quantity QASUM the intake air quantity QA calculated on the basis of the readings from the air flow meter 28. Although the first embodiment calculates the intake air quantity QA based on the readings of the air flow meter 28, this is not limitative of the invention. Alternatively, the intake air quantity QA may be estimated from the intake air pressure PM detected by the intake air pressure sensor and from the engine rotational speed Ne measured by the rotational speed sensor 25. The accumulated intake air quantity QASUM is initialized to “0” at the start-up of the engine. With the accumulated intake air quantity QASUM stored in step 502, the CPU 32 goes to step 503 in which a check is made to see of the value “QACLO” exceeds a predetermined deterioration reference value QACDT. If QACLO # QACDT, the CPU 32 terminates this routine immediately. If QACLO > QACDT, the CPU 32 enters step 504 in which the catalyst deterioration flag XCATDT is set to “1.” In step 505, the CPU 32 stores the deterioration information into the backup RAM 35 and executes a predetermined diagnostic process (e.g., illumination of the diagnostic lamp 29). In applying Yamashita against the appealed claims, the examiner says of the foregoing disclosure that “[e]lements corresponding to the engine load detector (column 10, lines 3-5), accumulator (column 9, lines 61-62), comparator (column 10, lines 12-15) and catalyst deterioration determiner (column 10, lines 4Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007