Ex Parte Aulick et al - Page 5




          Appeal No. 2002-1838                                                         
          Application 09/631,765                                                       

          line 3 through page 10, line 9 of the specification. At page 8,              
          lines 6 and 7, appellants disclose that the impregnating compound            
          "has a paste or caulk-like consistency." The terminology "paste" is          
          not otherwise defined in the specification. The second element, the          
          "rigid member with a supporting base", is disclosed as preferably            
          formed of cardboard to which the foam pad is adhesively attached.            
          See page 6, lines 26 through 28 of the specification and Figure 2,           
          element 16. Cardboard having a thickness of one eighth of an inch            
          (1/8") has been determined to be sufficient to furnish rigidity to           
          and support the porous member. See page 7, lines 12 through 15 of            
          the specification.                                                           
               Accordingly, claim 17 embraces a porous material, preferably            
          a polyurethane foam, supported by a supporting base, preferably              
          cardboard, and preferably adhesively attached to the base and a              
          rigid member supporting the foam. The porous member is impregnated           
          with a paste which comprises a silicone copolymer but claim 17 does          
          not describe the component comonomers.                                       
               We agree with the examiner that Latone discloses an assembly            
          for cleaning toner resins from components of a printing device. The          
          assembly comprises a porous member (see element 103 of the                   
          "cleaning roll" depicted in Figure 4) and a rigid member with a              
          supporting base on which said porous member is mounted (see element          
          101 in Figure 4). Latone also describes the preferred material for           
          the porous member as "urethane foam" (see column 5, lines 3 through          

                                          5                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007