Ex Parte O'BRIEN et al - Page 3




               Appeal No. 2002-1846                                                                                                   
               Application 09/146,199                                                                                                 
               A.      The rejection of Claims 17-20, 24, 26-36, and 39-45 as                                                         
                       Unpatentable over Mindrum, Bass, Orr, and Shimoda                                                              
                       Independent claims 20 and 36 appear the broadest and are reproduced below:                                     
                               20.   A point of sale system, comprising:                                                              
                               (a)   a terminal at a customer checkout location, said terminal having                                 
                       means for reading product codes on product items in a customer’s order;                                        
                               (b)   item record file means for storing price and product identification                              
                       information for product items;                                                                                 
                               (c)   a store controller with which said terminal can communicate, said                                
                       store controller in communication with said item record file; and                                              
                               (d)   means for collecting and storing system test data, said system test data                         
                       comprising a log of events including at least one of (1) loop error events, (2)                                
                       terminal reload events, (3) price change at the terminal events, and (4) item-not-                             
                       on-file events.                                                                                                
                               36.   A process comprising the steps of:                                                               
                               (a)   reading product codes on product items in a customer’s order using a                             
                       terminal at a customer checkout location;                                                                      
                               (b)   storing price and product identification information for product items                           
                       in an item record file;                                                                                        
                               (c)   transmitting price and product identification information from the                               
                       item record file to an [sic, a] store controller;                                                              
                               (d)   transmitting customer purchase data from said terminal to said store                             
                       controller; and                                                                                                
                               (e)   collecting and storing system test data, said system test data                                   
                       comprising a log of events including at least one of (1) loop error events, (2)                                
                       terminal reload events, (3) price change at the terminal events, and (4) item-not-                             
                       on-file events.                                                                                                
               Other independent claims in this case are claims 17-19 and claims 33-35.  Unlike claims 20 and                         
                                                                  3                                                                   





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007