Ex Parte PAGE - Page 15




                       d)      Dr. Youle testified that in mammalian cells, “the addition of a special ‘leader                        
               sequence’ would be required to steer the protein to the secretory pathway” that would be                               
               necessary “for any hope of proper glycosylation of the antibodies.”  According to Dr. Youle, the                       
               Cabilly application does not teach the addition of such a leader sequence (Exh. 2012 at ¶ 18).                         
                                                       A therapeutic method                                                           
                       46.     Glaxo argues that the Cabilly applications do not teach a therapeutic method as                        
               required by the ‘611 claims and proposed Count 2 (Paper 49 at 9-10 and Paper 51 at 20-21).                             
                       47.     Proposed Count 2 is directed to a method of treating one of the following:                             
                               a.      a human suffering from a disease or disorder (‘403 claim 1)                                    
                               b.      a human suffering from a T-cell mediated disorder (‘404 claim 1)                               
                               c.      a human suffering from cancer (‘405 claim 1)                                                   
                               d.      a human suffering from a disease (‘611 claim 53)                                               
                               e.      a human suffering from an attack by a substance or organism (‘611                              
                               claim 55)                                                                                              
                       48.     In a first portion of the application entitled “Background of the Invention”, the                      
               Cabilly applications state that (Exh. 2103 and Exh. 2102 at 3:26 to 4:2):                                              
                               In another important use, antibodies can be directly injected into subjects                            
                       suffering from an attack by a substance or organism containing the antigen in                                  
                       question to combat this attack.  This process is currently in its experimental                                 
                       stages, but its potential is clearly seen.  Third, whole body diagnosis and                                    
                       treatment is made possible because injected antibodies are directed to specific                                
                       target disease tissues, and thus can be used either to determine the presence of the                           
                       disease by carrying with them a suitable label, or to attack the diseased tissue by                            
                       carrying a suitable drug.                                                                                      
                       49.     In a second portion of the application entitled “Detailed Description”, the Cabilly                    
               applications state that chimeric antibodies having human constant regions are “less likely to                          



                                                                -15-                                                                  





Page:  Previous  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007