Ex Parte YUZAWA et al - Page 10



          Appeal No. 1999-0260                                                        
          Application 08/571,064                                                      
               In regard to claim 4 the Examiner adds17 "The Applicant also           
          detects that the fuses are inherently first and second detection            
          means which are set ON by blowing them."                                    
               In regard to claims 6 and 7 the Examiner points out18 that             
          Appellants' figure 11 discloses an interface for data exchange, a           
          register, a driver, and a power enabler.  The Examiner admits               
          that Appellants' prior art admission does not disclose a                    
          detection means and means for turning the driver off, or storing            
          the result of the detection means.                                          
               The Examiner then points19 to Price for teaching a detection           
          means and states Price "inherently discloses turning off the                
          driver" and "inherently discloses storing the results . . .                 
          since the connection isn't reestablished until the current                  
          condition is removed."  The Examiner then finds20 that it would             
          have been obvious to a person of ordinary skill in the art, at              
          the time of the invention, to have turned the driver off because            
          this would conserve power, since no data would be transmitted               
          when an over-current occurs.                                                

               17 Final, pages 3-4, section c                                         
               18 Final, page 4, section e                                            
               19 Final, page 4, section e                                            
               20 Final, pages 4-5, section e                                         
                                         10                                           




Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007