Ex Parte KOTTAPURATH et al - Page 4




              Appeal No. 1999-2255                                                                                        
              Application No. 08/885,393                                                                                  

              that Cole describes, at column 3, lines 45-55, the BIOS containing instruction codes for                    
              booting the system.  The examiner further refers to material in the figures and Abstract                    
              of Cole.                                                                                                    
                     Claim 1 recites “a startup program which is configured to run when the local                         
              computer is started up.”  The “startup program” is further configured to interrogate the                    
              identifier program and run the updater program if the current computer program does                         
              not correspond to the latest computer program.                                                              
                     We agree with appellants that Cole fails to disclose a “startup program” as                          
              required by instant claim 1.  As described by Cole (col. 3, ll. 7-55), a user at client                     
              computer 14 (Fig. 2) selects an icon to invoke update manager 32.  First, the programs                      
              residing on client computer 14 (e.g., scout 33) that are mainly responsible for updating                    
              other programs on the computer are checked to determine if those programs                                   
              correspond to the latest versions.  If not, the server sends FTP addressing information                     
              for the latest versions, and the client downloads and installs the latest versions of those                 
              programs on the client computer which serve for the general updating of the remainder                       
              of the computer.                                                                                            
                     The system BIOS of the client computer is mentioned at column 3, lines 45                            
              through 55 of the reference.  However, the reference to the BIOS is within the context                      
              of providing examples of the client computer’s basic system information which is sent to                    
              the selection server 12, for determining which code updates are consistent with that                        
              particular client computer (col. 3, l. 56 - col. 4, l. 1).                                                  
                                                           -4-                                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007