Ex Parte TARBOX et al - Page 7




          Appeal No. 2001-0374                                                         
          Application No. 08/971,255                                                   

          interactively selecting the attribute to be transiently displayed            
          for a selected time period.                                                  
               Pitchaikani, on the other hand, relates to acquiring and                
          displaying object attribute data from a database in a pop-up                 
          window by identifying the agent running on a device and its                  
          corresponding objects.  As depicted in Figures 1 and 5, after                
          signals indicative of the agent and the corresponding objects are            
          sent by the display mechanism 120, values corresponding to the               
          objects are retrieved and displayed in a pop-up window (col. 7,              
          lines 10-41).  The pop-up window is shown in Figure 3 as                     
          containing network code 302, device description 304, attribute               
          category 306 and attribute identifiers/values 308/310 (col. 11,              
          lines 1-13).  The pop-up window further includes reset button 312            
          which causes new values to be retrieved and displayed for                    
          attributes 308 in attribute value area 310 (col. 11, lines 13-               
          22).                                                                         
               Although we acknowledge that Pitchaikani’s reset button                 
          modifies the content of the pop-up window, it neither selects the            
          attribute to be transiently displayed nor activates for a                    
          selected time period a transient display of a selected attribute.            
          Therefore, contrary to the Examiner’s proposed combination of the            
          pop-up window of Pitchaikani with the data display system of                 

                                          7                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007