Ex Parte LEE et al - Page 13




          Appeal No. 2001-0740                                                        
          Application 09/054,415                                                      

          is steered "away from" current mirror 61, as claimed, or that               
          current I0 is steered "away from" current mirror 67.  The                   
          rejection of claim 12 is reversed.                                          

               Claim 13                                                               
               Appellants argue that Mizuide does not show "selectively               
          activating a second power source in conjunction with a first                
          power source during part of a recurring time interval" as recited           
          in claim 13 (Br12).                                                         
               The examiner responds that second power source 61 is                   
          selectively activated with first power source 55, which is always           
          on, during a part of a recurring interval, referring to column 7,           
          lines 34-36 and 41-43 (EA15).                                               
               While we agree with the examiner's finding that current                
          mirror 61 being activated in conjunction with current mirror 55             
          meets the limitation of "selectively activating a second power              
          source in conjunction with a first power source," we do not find            
          "a recurring time interval" disclosed in Mizuide.  We interpret             
          "a recurring time interval" to require a time interval that is              
          repeated, which is not shown in Mizuide, and the examiner has not           
          offered any interpretation that would be met by Mizuide.  The               
          rejection of claim 13 is reversed.                                          

               Claim 15                                                               


                                       - 13 -                                         





Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007