Ex Parte FLYNN et al - Page 5




          Appeal No. 2001-1196                                                        
          Application No. 09/139,155                                                  


          "does not describe electrically connecting two leads to a single            
          port."  Appellants conclude (Brief, page 6) that Stutz fails to             
          teach providing a lead "with an adapter as part of the lead."  We           
          agree that Stutz does not disclose an adapting member nor                   
          connecting two leads to a single port.  However, the rejection is           
          over Stutz in view of Fain, and the examiner applies Fain for               
          these two limitations.  As to a lead with an adapter as part of             
          the lead, claim 1 is not so limited.  Claim 1 requires that the             
          adapter extend from the lead, but that differs from being a part            
          of the lead.  The adapter can extend from the lead without being            
          formed as a part of the lead.                                               
               Similarly, appellants argue (Brief, page 6) that Fain fails            
          to suggest a lead "having an adapting member formed as part of              
          the lead."  As explained supra, the claims are not so limited.              
          Appellants also argue (Brief, page 6) that Fain fails to describe           
          connecting multiple leads to a single port, as "Fain requires the           
          same number of ports as number of leads used."  We disagree.                
          Fain discloses (column 8, lines 40-60) that connector blocks for            
          leads 42 and 44 are both electrically connected to lead connector           
          50, which in turn connects to the header, and connector 51 serves           
          as a dummy lead connector, since no connector blocks are                    
          connected thereto.                                                          
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007