Appeal No. 2001-1605 Application 08/735,168 Figures 3 and 4 describe how Bireley solves the problem of query parallelism. See column 10, lines 53 through 55. The high level control flow of query parallelism is described in figures 5A and 5B. See column 11, lines 36 through 40. In step 504, shown in figure 5A, the originating database management system binds the query thereby creating a plan for executing the query. See column 11, lines 47 through 52, of Bireley. The operation of the originating database management system during the buying time shown in step 504 is represented by a control flow diagram shown in figure 6. Thus, the portion of Bireley which the Examiner relies on for disclosing partitioning a database into several partitions and reading an access request to such data wherein access to a partition database is deemed to contain a plurality of partitions is directed to the method of determining query parallelism. This portion of Bireley, column 12, lines 20 through 63, is describing the operation of the original database management during the buying time in which the database management system decomposes the query into multiple parallel tasks and allocates the parallel tasks across to the other database management systems. We agree with the Examiner that this portion of Bireley does teach that the data is in partitioned tablespace located in separate physical storage 10Page: Previous 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007