Ex Parte VOGMAN - Page 15




          Appeal No. 2001-1627                                                        
          Application No. 09/289,420                                Page 15           

          claim 1.  Appellant asserts (brief, page 11) that Yasumura does             
          not meet the recited claim limitation directed to the use of an             
          inductor in contrast to a transformer.  We make reference to our            
          construction of claim 1, supra.  We find that the primary coil N1           
          and secondary coil Ni of MCT meet the claimed "two-coil inductor"           
          based upon our determinations, supra, with respect to the                   
          construction of claim 1.  Appellants argue (id.) that Yasumura              
          does not meet the claimed "input voltage ratio to output voltage            
          ratio capable of being equal to, greater than, or less than one."           
          The voltage ratios of Yasumura inherently meet this limitation              
          because whatever the ratio is, it is inherently within the set of           


          numbers defined by greater than one, equal to one or less than              
          one.                                                                        
               Appellant further argues that Yasumura does not meet the               
          claimed "alternative coils of a two-coil inductor are employed in           
          a primary and secondary circuit loop."  We find that this                   
          limitation is met by Yasumura based our findings, supra, with               
          respect to claim construction of claim 1.                                   
               It is further argued that the limitation regarding the                 
          "input and output voltages having the same polarity" is not met.            
          We find from the disclosure of Yasumura that secondary winding Ni           








Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007