Appeal No. 2001-2407
Application No. 09/154,703
there is no disclosure of structural details for an actuator
driven by either electrostatic force or electromagnetic force,
the specification does describe the actuator structure including
a drive portion and a movable portion, along with electrodes to
supply current to the coil. See page 8, line 22-page 9, line 1,
page 12, lines 21-23 and page 23, line 20-page 24, line 4. The
artisan would have understood from this disclosure that the
actuator would be driven by either electrostatic force or
electromagnetic force and would further have understood how to
perform these tasks. Moreover, such actuators were known to
skilled artisans and, as the examiner states, at page 6 of the
answer, the rejection would be withdrawn if the actuators were
known. It is clear to us that the actuators, per se, were known.
The instant inventive features are directed, not to the
actuators, but to the slider structure upon which the actuator
rests.
With regard to claim 13/9, the examiner states that although
the claim recites a range of thickness for the slider and
actuator assembly, and appellants cite several passages in the
disclosure, enabling the listed dimensions, the cited passages
“merely state the dimensions listed in the claims. The entire
disclosure is simply schematic in nature. There is no showing of
-8–
Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Next
Last modified: November 3, 2007