Ex Parte ZAPPACOSTA - Page 5




          Appeal No. 2002-0555                                                        
          Application 09/361,514                                                      


          plurality of depending force exerting members (26), wherein the             
          depending force exerting members engage the mounting bracket of             
          the at least one electronic circuit board set forth in the claim            
          when the retention bracket is secured to the mounting panel by              
          fasteners (50), and argues that the examiner’s reading of the               
          above-noted “depending force exerting members” on the alignment             
          or fixing protrusions (30c) of cover member (30) of Lee is in               
          error. More particularly, appellant urges that the pins (30c) of            
          Lee are not force exerting members but only pass through the                
          groove (26c) of the mounting bracket/support member (26) as                 
          locating pins and act solely to align and prevent the                       
          disengagement of the mounting bracket (26) from the mounting                
          panel (16) after assembly.                                                  


          Like appellant, our review of the Lee patent reveals that                   
          the protrusions or pins (30c) on the cover (30) therein extend              
          through the grooves (26c) of the mounting brackets (26) and into            
          holes (16c) of the mounting panel/receptacle (16) and act                   
          primarily as locating and alignment pins for proper positioning             
          of the mounting brackets (26), particularly end portions (26a)              
          thereof, relative to the mounting panel/receptacle (16). There is           
          no indication and apparently no need in the arrangement seen in             
                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007