Ex Parte MAYER - Page 3


          Appeal No. 2002-0902                                                        
          Application No. 09/231,672                                                  

               The examiner relies on the following prior art reference as            
          evidence of unpatentability:                                                
          Laapotti                5,868,904           Feb. 9, 1999                   
                                                (filed May  6, 1997)                  
               Claims 1 through 20 on appeal stand rejected under 35                  
          U.S.C. § 103(a) as unpatentable over Laapotti.  (Examiner’s                 
          answer of Apr. 10, 2001, paper 14, pages 2-3.)                              
               We reverse this rejection.                                             
               Laapotti discloses a press section of a paper making                   
          machine comprising a first extended nip NP1, which is formed                
          between press roll 13 and hose roll 20, and a first roll nip N1,            
          which is formed between a press roll 15 and a center roll 30.               
          (Figure 6.)  Laapotti further teaches that the press felts 11               
          and 28 contact the two sides of the web at NP1 and that felt 11             
          and a transfer band loop 60a contact the two sides of the web at            
          N1.  (Column 6, lines 38-48; column 14, lines 50-56.)  According            
          to Laapotti, “[t]he surface of the transfer band loop 60a that              
          contacts the paper web is preferably smooth, and the transfer               
          band loop 60a itself is preferably comprised of a materials                 
          [sic] known in the art, preferably one that is water permeable              
          and may also or instead one that is water absorbing.”  (Column              
          14, lines 56-61.)                                                           



                                          3                                           


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007