Ex Parte KIM - Page 9




          Appeal No. 2002-1705                                                        
          Application 09/132,751                                                      


          segmentation system of the implement embodiment in column 5, line           
          45, through column 7, line 28.  Cullen teaches compression of the           
          bit-mapped representation in column 7, line 29, through column 8,           
          line 50.  Cullen teaches run length extraction and classification           
          in column 8, line 51, through column 10, line 41.  Cullen teaches           
          rectangular construction and initial classification in column 10,           
          line 42, through column 14, line 51.  Cullen teaches skew                   
          detection in column 14, line 52, through column 16, line 26.                
          Cullen teaches skew angle correction of the constructed                     
          rectangles in column 16, line 28 through column 17, line 46.                
          Finally, Cullen teaches verification of rectangle classification            
          in column 17, line 48 through column 21, line 4.                            
               From a careful reading of Cullen, we find that Cullen is               
          determining skew, correction of skew, classifying and merging.              
          We fail to find that Cullen teaches shifting each dot of a dot              
          image formed by a rasterized block according to a set of pre-               
          stored correction values as recited in Appellant’s claims 1                 
          through 4.  Furthermore, we fail to find that Cullen teaches                














Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007