Ex Parte ODER - Page 2




          Appeal No. 2002-1828                                                         
          Application 09/424,606                                                       


          control unit of an internal combustion engine (claim 24), and an             
          internal combustion engine including such a control unit (claim              
          27), wherein an optimal switchover is possible between stratified            
          fuel injection operation during a compression phase (first mode)             
          and homogeneous operation during an intake phase (second mode),              
          with the switchover taking place from the first mode initially to            
          a transitional operation of the second mode and then to normal               
          operation of the second mode, thereby leading to a significantly             
          lower increase of the torque generated by the internal combustion            
          engine at the time of such switchover.  Independent claims 12, 24            
          and 27 are representative of the subject matter on appeal and a              
          copy of those claims can be found in Appendix A of appellant’s               
          brief.                                                                       


          The prior art references of record relied upon by the                        
          examiner in rejecting the appealed claims are:                               
          Iida et al. (Iida ‘947)             5,970,947      Oct. 26, 1999             
          Kamura et al. (Kamura)      WO 98/090631           Mar.  5, 1998             

               1  Our understanding of the above-noted foreign language                
          document (WO 98/09063) relied upon by the examiner is based on an            
          English language equivalent, U.S. Patent No. 5,975,044.  The                 
          examiner makes clear on page 3 of the answer (Paper No. 14) that             
          it is the publication date of March 5, 1998 of WO 98/09063 that              
          is being relied upon.  Appellant has not disputed that this                  
          document is prior art to him.                                                
                                           2                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007