Ex Parte ABERSFELDER et al - Page 8




          Appeal No. 2002-1849                                       Page 8           
          Application No. 09/116,710                                                  


          specified [in the claims], and asserts (id.) that Branca was                
          introduced to show the particular feature of intrinsic surface              
          coloration.  The examiner asserts (answer, page 5) that Branca              
          teaches the use of a holographic screen wherein a property of a             
          surface of the holographic screen is that it has an intrinsic               
          coloration which is one of black, grey and a dark color.  The               
          examiner points to col. 3, lines 20-31, lines 40-44, col. 9,                
          lines 26-30 and 38-48, and col. 2, lines 37-46.                             
               Appellants assert (brief, pages 8 and 9) that Branca is                
          directed to a color compensation arrangement which compensates              
          for the fact that polarizers used in the display create a                   
          distinctly perceptible hue, for example "bluish", "redish", etc,            
          and that Branca provides a chromatically adjusted display which             
          is diffusely illuminated by and viewable under ambient light.  It           
          is argued (id.) that Branca provides a liquid crystal display,              
          not a holographic display, and does not teach or suggest the use            
          of a holographic screen which is black, grey or a dark color in             
          ambient light.  It is further argued (brief, page 9) that the               
          purpose of the holographic diffuser element in Branca is to                 
          achieve uniformity of illumination, and that Branca discloses the           
          use of reflective pigments into light reflective layer 110 which            
          is applied to the holographic transmission diffuser.                        







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007