Ex Parte MEIXNER - Page 11




          Appeal No. 2002-1850                                                        
          Application 08/288,574                                                      


          optional biaxially stretching step, the Korlatzki reference, like           
          appellant (specification, page 9; Fig. 8a), expressly teaches a             
          multi-layer casing of polyurethane (highly elastic) and PVDC (gas           
          impermeable) (column 3, lines 2 through 6, and column 5, lines 12           
          through 17 and 40 through 52) which lies taught and absolutely              
          wrinkle-free against food material content (column 6, lines 34              
          through 36).                                                                


               In light of the above findings relative to the materials and           
          characteristics of the multi-layer casing of Korlatzki, we                  
          determine that the Korlatzki patent responds to all features of             
          the packaging envelope in combination with formable meat set                
          forth in appellant’s claim 1, i.e., the casing of Korlatzki is              
          capable of and would be expected to stretch immediately before              
          and upon placement of formable meat therein, the casing would               
          spontaneously contract after placement of meat and automatically            
          force out air between the casing and the meat, and the casing               
          would force the formable meat into a nearly circular cross-                 
          section shape.                                                              


               It is for the above reasons that the anticipation rejection            
          of claim 1 is sustained.                                                    

                                         11                                           





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007