Ex Parte Torbus et al - Page 2




         Appeal No. 2002-2063                                                       
         Application No. 09/635,093                                                 
              (a) a phenolic resin component consisting essentially of at           
         least (i) one phenolic resin exhibiting free phenolic and free             
         alcoholic OH-groups and (ii) a solvent for the phenolic resin; and         
              (b) a polyisocyanate component consisting essentially of (i)          
         at least one polyisocyanate capable of reacting with said phenolic         
         resin exhibiting free phenolic and free alcoholic OH-groups to             
         form a resin therewith and (ii) a solvent for said polyisocyanate;         
              wherein said solvent (b) (ii) for said polyisocyanate is              
         comprised at least in part of a fatty acid methyl ester, wherein           
         said fatty acid methyl ester is a methyl monoester of one or more          
         fatty acids with a carbon chain of twelve or more carbon atoms,            
         and wherein said solvent (b)(ii) for said polyisocyanate contains          
         more fatty acid methyl ester than high-boiling aromatic                    
         hydrocarbon.                                                               
                                    The Reference                                   
              In rejecting the claims under 35 U.S.C. § 103(a), the                 
         examiner relies upon the following reference:                              
         Furness et al. (Furness)      3,904,559           Sep. 09, 1975            
                                    The Rejection                                   
              Claims 12-29 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103(a) as being         
         unpatentable over Furness.                                                 
                                    The Invention                                   
              The invention relates to a two-component polyurethane-based           
         binder system which consists essentially of a phenolic resin and a         
         solvent for the phenolic resin, a polyisocyanate and a solvent for         
         the polyisocyanate which contains more fatty acid methyl esters            
         (FAME) than high-boiling aromatic hydrocarbons.  (Appeal Brief,            
         page 1, line 13 - page 4, line 19).                                        


                                         2                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007