Ex Parte STIPPLER et al - Page 4




          Appeal No. 2003-0729                                                        
          Application 08/914,346                                                      


               The system for the automatic control comprises a                       
               differential manometer 8, a secondary device 9 with a                  
               signaling device, a panel 10, a level indicator 11, a                  
               function unit 12, a setter [set-point adjuster] 13, a                  
               regulator 14, a control valve 15, a flow-rate meter 16,                
               a measuring device 17 of the position of the ripper, an                
               indicator 18 of the position of the ripper, a                          
               programming device [software] 19.                                      
               The initial flow rate from the feed tank 5, which                      
               ensures a difference of 100 mm between the level of the                
               wort in the filtering vat 1 and that in the feed tank,                 
               is preset by means of the setter 13.  Over the course                  
               of the filtration, the controlling effect is imparted                  
               onto the valve 15, which controlling effect is                         
               determined by the relationship established in the                      
               regulating device 14 between the set-point and the                     
               flow-rate of the wort as well as by the correcting                     
               effect brought about by the level indicator 11 via the                 
               function unit 12 based on the level in the feed tank.                  
               When the friction of the mash increases, the                           
               difference between the levels in the filtration vat and                
               the feed tank also increases whereby the level drop is                 
               measured by the differential manometer 8.  The ultimate                
               value of this differential is indicated by means of a                  
               signal on the panel 10.  Besides this, the said signal                 
               is transmitted to the programming unit 19 which                        
               automatically controls the ripper.  The feedback                       
               according to the position of the ripper and the remote                 
               control over this position is carried out by the                       
               measuring device 17 and the indicator 18 of the                        
               position of the ripper [translation, pages 2 and 3].                   
               Conceding that Zhekov does not meet the limitations in                 
          independent claim 1 relating to the last four method steps or the           
          limitations in independent claim 20 relating to the discharge               
          control (see page 4 in the answer), the examiner takes two                  
          approaches to cure these deficiencies.                                      



                                          4                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007