Ex Parte McElroy et al - Page 14




         Appeal No. 2003-0936                                                       
         Application No. 09/532,806                                                 


         and use the full scope of the subject matter claimed is well within        
         the knowledge and skill of a person with the ordinary level of             
         knowledge and skill in this art to perform without undue                   
         experimentation.  For example, appellants’ specification teaches           
         (Spec., pp. 12-13; emphasis added)):                                       
              [T]he current invention includes sequences which have                 
              been derived from the maize GRP promoter disclosed                    
              herein.  One efficient means for preparing such                       
              derivatives comprises introducing mutations into the                  
              sequences of the invention, for example, the sequence                 
              given in SEQ ID NO:1.  Such mutants may potentially                   
              have enhanced or altered function relative to the                     
              native sequence or alternatively, may be silent with                  
              regard to function.                                                   
                   Mutagenesis may be carried out at random and the                 
              mutagenized sequences screened for function in a trial-               
              by-error procedure.  Alternatively, particular sequences              
              which provide the ZMGRP promoter with desirable expression            
              characteristics could be identified and these or similar              
              sequences introduced into other related or non-related                
              sequences via mutation.  Similarly, non-essential elements            
              may be deleted without significantly altering the function            
              of the elements.  It further is contemplated that one                 
              could mutagenize these sequences in order to enhance                  
              their utility in expressing transgenes in a particular                
              species, for example, maize.                                          
                   The means for mutagenizing a DNA segment encoding a              
              ZMGRP promoter sequence of the current invention are well-            
              known to those of skill in the art.  Mutagenesis may be               
              performed in accordance with any of the techniques known              
              in the art, such as, but not limited to, synthesizing an              
              oligonucleotide having one or more mutations within the               
              sequence of a particular regulatory region.  In particular,           
              site-specific mutagenesis is a technique useful in                    
              the preparation of promoter mutants, through specific                 
              mutagenesis of the underlying DNA.  The technique further             

                                         14                                         





Page:  Previous  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007