FURMAN et al. V. BELLEAU et al. - Page 33





             their structure, since the identify of the Liotta samples was unknown to the Furman inventors at         
             the time. (FFs 241-L and 33A).                                                                           
             Ms. Kond 's testinion                                                                                    
                    Shelia (Smith) Kondy testified that she sent samples "from George Painter to Dr. Korba            
             for HBV testing". Ms. Kondy's testimony does not say why she sent BCH- 189 for the testing.              
             For example, Ms. Kondy's testimony does not state that either of the Furman inventors asked her          
             to send BCH- 189 for anti-HBV testing.                                                                   
                    We note that Ms. Kondy's notebook entry dated 31 October 1990 contains a notation                 
             "from G. Painter" under which are listed six compounds, one of which is BCH- 189. (FF47).                
             Ms. Kondy's notebook entry is consistent with other evidence indicating that BCH- 189 was                
             received into BW by Dr. Painter (e.g., FFs 241 and 33A) and thus was "from G. Painter".                  
             However, the notebook entry is not sufficient to show that a Funnan inventor explicitly asked            
             Ms. Kondy to send BCH- 189 for anti-HBV testing. Furman does not argue that and therefore we             
             will not speculate as to whether Ms. Kondy sent BCH- 189 to Dr. Korba at the implicit request of         
             a Furman inventor.                                                                                       
             Dr. Biron's testimony                                                                                    
                    Karen Biron testified that she would conduct a meeting to discuss "sample priority" since         
             there were a limited number of samples that could be tested by Dr. Korba at any time. (FF 40).           
             In her testimony, Dr. Biron refers to a memorandum dated 13 October 1989. (FF 41-42). The                
             memorandum states that "[flhere will be a meeting to select the next ten compounds for testing           
             against human HBV by Brent Korba of Georgetown". Neither Dr. Painter nor Dr. Furman is on                
             the distribution list found at the bottom of the memorandum. It is not clear to us if the                

                                                         33                                                           







Page:  Previous  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  38  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007