Ex Parte POWELL - Page 11





                              cutting on Mr. Bernardy's blade stock. Mr. Powell made no                                                    
                              invention claims at the time.                                                                                
                              5. 1 have reviewed the Patent 5,875,700 later issued to Mr.                                                  
                              Powell and it has all of the elements of the early prototype of                                              
                              the blade shown to me in February 1997. At the time, I was                                                   
                              told so by Mr. Powell and 1 had no reason to doubt that Mr.                                                  
                              Bernardy was the true inventor of the blade.                                                                 

              31. Mr. Egbert testifies that he reviewed the '700 patent and saw early prototypes of a                                      

                      blade in February of 1997 which had all the elements of the '700 blade. However,                                     
                      on cross examination (Powell Record page 146 to 149), he states:                                                     
                              Q. My first question to you is, is everything in this affidavit                                              
                                      100 percent true and correct?                                                                        
                              A. No ....                                                                                                   
                              Q ....         do you recall Bob Powell introducing Mr.                                                      
                                      Bernardy as the inventor of the blade?                                                               
                              1 . Yes.                                                                                                     
                              Q. Did they have a blade with them?                                                                          
                              A. Yes.                                                                                                      
                              Q. Was it considered a prototype of the blade?                                                               
                              A. As far as I know.                                                                                         
                              Q. Can you describe what you saw?                                                                            
                              A. All I saw was a flat blade, at that time.                                                                 
                              Q. And they had no things flipped up like this (indicating)?                                                 
                              A. No. Not at the time.                                                                                      
                              Q. There were no, what we'll call, shredding elements                                                        
                                      extending up from the bottom of the blade?                                                           
                              A. I don't remember. I saw some cuts on the blade.                                                           
                              Q. But no - they weren't flipped off, or there were no                                                       
                                      teeth on them, that you recall?                                                                      
                              A. I sure don't remember.                                                                                    
                              Q. So to the best of your recollection - am I correct in                                                     
                                      saying that to the best of your recollection, the blade                                              
                                      you saw was a flat disk, and may or may not have had                                                 
                                      some cuts in it?                                                                                     
                              A. It had cuts in it. But it was flat, at the time.                                                          
                              Q ....         You say that you reviewed patent No. 5875700                                                  
                              A. I didn't review no patent.                                                                                
                              Q. You did not review a patent?                                                                              








Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007