STICE et al. V. STICE et al. V. STRELCHENKO et al. V. HENSEN et al. - Page 27





                                  7. Mammalian cells other than the gametes (with the exception of those cells,                                        
                                  such as mature red blood cells, having no nucleus and hence no nuclear                                               
                                  material) are normally polyploid having two sets of each chromosome                                                  
                                  (diploid) during most phases of the cell cycle and four sets of each                                                 
                                  chromosome (tetraploid) during certain stages of the synthesis and mitosis                                           
                                  phases.                                                                                                              
                                  8. Not all genn cells are or even become, gametes.                                                                   
                                  9. Haploid cells may not by themselves, give rise to a new mammal and are                                            
                                  therefore not "totipotent" under the definition provided in the '445                                                 
                                  Application, or given the ordinary meaning of "totipotent" as defined in the                                         
                                  Joint Glossary; totipotent cells are limited to cells which are polyploid.                                           
                                  12. "Totipotent" as defined in the '445 Application and as understood by a                                           
                                  person of ordinary skill in the art at the time of the disclosure, therefore refers                                  
                                  to polyploid cells capable of generating a developing cell mass, or embryo                                           
                                  when used in the NT process. Step (a) of Claim 48 employs the term                                                   
                                  "totipotent mammalian cell," meaning a mammalian cell that, when, used in                                            
                                  the NT process, is capable of developing into an organism Claim 106                                                  
                                  specifies that the "reprogrammed cell is totipotent," meaning capable of                                             
                                  developing into an organism. Claim 107, by depending from Claim 106, also                                            
                                  contains the limitation that the "reprogrammed cell is totipotent," meaning                                          
                                  capable of developing into an organism                                                                               
                                  13. Mammalian gametes, being haploid, are not totipotent cells.                                                      
                                  14. Totipotent cells are cells of a multicellular organism that are not                                              
                                  mammalian gametes.                                                                                                   
                                  15. A totipotent cell is therefore a somatic cell (as defined in the Glossary)                                       
                                  that has thepotential to generate a developing cell mass, i.e., an embryo when                                       
                                  used as the donor cell in the NT process.                                                                            
                         Strelchenko Ex. 2034, pp. 2-3, 115-15                                                                                         
                                                                        b.                                                                             
                         Strelchenko's argument is not persuasive and we do not credit Dr. Forsberg's testimony on                                     
                thispoint. Strelchenko's argument as to the meaning of somatic and totipotent is inconsistent with                                     
                the ordinary meanings of those words and, more importantly, their uses in Strelchenko's                                                
                specification. In their ordinary meanings in the art, somatic and totipotent are mutually exclusive.                                   

                                                                       -27-                                                                            








Page:  Previous  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007