Appeal No. 2001-0922 Application No. 09/408,886 disclosed by Powell. Based upon the noted teachings of Powell, we find that Powell clearly discloses “encoding said auxiliary [data] in tiled fashion, both vertically and horizontally” as required by claim 7 if the embedded signatures in Powell are in a regular and widely spaced pattern across the image. With respect to claim 12, each of the embedded signature points in the image in Powell “corresponds to one of said image elements” (column 2, lines 34 through 50). Appellant’s request has been granted to the extent that our decision has been reconsidered, but such request is denied with respect to making any modifications to the decision. 3Page: Previous 1 2 3 4 5 NextLast modified: November 3, 2007