Ex Parte IYER - Page 2




          Appeal No. 2001-0336                                                        
          Application No. 09/059,865                                                  

               Appellant argues on pages 1 through 5 of the request that              
          the Board held that the term "stringer" means undesirable                   
          residual non-dielectric material in accordance with the meaning             
          found in the specification and in accordance with the manner in             
          which the term is commonly understood by those of ordinary skill            
          in the art of semiconductor fabrication.  Appellant points to               
          page 13, line 29 to page 14, line 2 of the specification which              
          describes stringers as being undesirable because they cause                 
          problems, such as gate leakage for example.  Appellant directs              
          the Board to page 22 of Plasma Processing Material; Scientific              
          Opportunities and Technological Challenges, Exhibit 1, which                
          describes "stringer" residue as being undesirable residual non-             
          dielectric material.                                                        
               Upon our careful review of the specification and extrinsic             
          evidence now made of record, we agree with the Appellant that the           
          proper meaning of the claimed term "stringer" is an undesirable             
          residual non-dielectric material.  We note that claim 12 requires           
          the limitation "removing a portion of the layer of non-dielectric           
          material, leaving stringers of the non-dielectric material in the           
          creases."  We find that the scope of this limitation is removing            
          a portion of the layer of non-dielectric material, leaving an               
          undesirable residual non-dielectric material in the creases.                

                                          22                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007