Ex Parte SNOVER - Page 5




            Appeal No. 2002-0367                                                                       
            Application No. 09/108,147                                                                 


            not met that burden in the instant case.                                                   


                  Taking claim 1, the important elements of which are present                          
            in each and every claim, the examiner says that the “means for                             
            predetermining a plurality of computing components to be                                   
            selectively added to said operation” is taught by Garvey at                                
            column 5, lines 1-2 (“window selector 480 allows the user to                               
            select other setup windows for setting up remote access server                             
            parameters”).  The examiner cites column 4, lines 21-22, of                                
            Garvey (“Referring... to FIG. 3, the remote access server manager                          
            window 300 provides a list 310 of the remote access servers                                
            coupled to the network”) as a teaching of the claimed “means for                           
            displaying a plurality of system elements.” For the claimed                                
            “means for predetermining at least one invocative attribute for                            
            each of said elements,” the examiner relies on the teaching, by                            
            Garvey, of “To edit the parameters for a particular async                                  
            interface port, the async interface port is selected and then the                          
            edit port button 690 is selected” at column 5, lines 11-13, and                            
            “To learn more about a particular remote access server, the user                           
            selects a remote access server from the list and then selects the                          
            comm. server info button 340.”                                                             
                  For the teaching of the claimed “means responsive to the                             

                                                 -5–                                                   





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007