Ex Parte CRAGUN - Page 6




          Appeal No. 2002-0648                                                       
          Application 09/090,698                                                     


          11 of the brief as a challenge to the examiner's previous                  
          assertion that the use of search engines was known in the art.             
          The evidence provided by the examiner at page 10 of the answer,            
          which is not challenged by appellant in any reply brief since no           
          reply brief has been filed, indicates that it was well-known that          
          search engines were well-known in the art according to the                 
          documents listed having a date of 1995, which clearly precedes             
          the filing date of this application.  Even though we recognize             
          that the references relied on for the rejection do not clearly             
          teach or suggest the use of search engines, the evidence provided          
          by the examiner here indicates that such are well-known in the             
          art.  It is also clear to us that the search engines may provide           
          a response as indicating a plurality of search results.  In                
          closing as to these claims, we note that at least the Abstract             
          of Earl indicates that a modified resource identifier or address           
          clearly is used as a second address for accessing purposes at              
          least a second or a plurality of successive times according to             
          his teachings.                                                             
               We turn now to the subject matter of independent claims 10,           
          22 and 34 which correspondingly recite methods, apparatus and              
          program products focusing upon the creation of a list of domains           
          and names by removing user-selected common address-components.             

                                          6                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007