Ex Parte KENYON et al - Page 4




              Appeal No. 2002-1079                                                                                        
              Application No. 09/124,540                                                                                  

              recitation “merely reads on the fact that new messages are stored (see Figure 4).”                          
              (Final Rejection at 4-5.)                                                                                   
                     Malone discloses, at column 6, line 40 et seq. that collections of objects may be                    
              grouped together into objects called Folders.  Agents may automatically process                             
              information on behalf of the users.  An agent may be triggered by events such as the                        
              arrival of new mail.  When an agent is triggered it applies a set of rules to a specified                   
              collection of objects, and performs actions such as receiving, classifying, mailing, and                    
              deleting objects or object-specific actions.                                                                
                     Malone further teaches that objects may be added to a folder (e.g., a Folder                         
              object) in two ways: automatically; or manually.  In either case, the folder will contain                   
              links to the objects, rather than the objects themselves.  Col. 9, ll. 25-35.                               
                     The examiner also relies on material at column 11 of Malone for teaching the                         
              claimed step that includes “automatically and dynamically establishing a link between                       
              the digital information object and each concept node....”  We find the following                            
              description at column 11 of the reference.                                                                  
                     Creating Agents and Rules                                                                            
                            In some cases, agents can take actions automatically on behalf of                             
                     their users.  For instance, FIG. 4 shows an example of a simple agent                                
                     designed to help a user process incoming mail.  When an agent is                                     
                     triggered, it applies a set of rules to a collection of objects in a folder.  The                    
                     agent in FIG. 4 is applied to objects in the New Mail folder and is triggered                        
                     by the arrival of new mail.  That is, when mail is retrieved to the                                  
                     workstation, the mail program automatically inserts links to the new                                 
                     messages into the user's New Mail folder and these New Links trigger the                             

                                                           -4-                                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007